According to the blu ray commentary from James L. Neibaur, there is some dispute as to how Lewis actually ended up in the role, though the perennially highbrowed Vidal probably experienced a certain amount of agita at Lewis’s presence and in particular the alterations to his original play which put the kibosh on the playwright’s anti-war sentiments and substitutes a series of comedic set-pieces for Lewis who plays Kreton, an infantile astronaut newly arrived from an undetermined planet far, far away.

Once on earth Lewis trades in his shiny aluminum spacesuit for a confederate colonel’s outfit (he was hoping to catch a skirmish or two during the Civil War) but the movie doesn’t wander near any politically potent gags about Kreton’s fascination with our tragic war over slavery or, really, war in general. Though screenwriters Edmund Beloin and Henry Garson steer clear of Vidal’s polemics, some fairly queasy sex jokes remain (Kreton’s planet is populated by neutered killjoys), turning Lewis into the creepiest voyeur since Carl Boehm in Peeping Tom.
For a nicely-budgeted movie based on a television broadcast, most of the time it looks like it never left the boob tube; Lewis is surrounded by the likes of Fred Clark and Gale Gordon, terrific but one-note actors who, if not already staples of TV, would soon be heading there (though there is a Maltese Falcon reunion between Jerome Cowan and Lee Patrick as part of the dithering throng). It’s telling that the most memorable sequence is a loose-limbed dance with sultry beatnik Barbara Lawson backed by Buddy Rich.
Kino Lorber’s blu ray looks sharp as a tack though Loyal Griggs’ black and white cinematography is pretty uninspired, especially in contrast to his (literally) epic work in films like The Ten Commandments and the lush storybook hues of 1953’s Shane. Save for the aforementioned Mr. Heibaur’s commentary and a small selection of trailers, there are no extras.
You can order Shawn Levy’s King of Comedy: The Life and Art of Jerry Lewis here.
And it would be remiss not to feature Martin Short’s ingenious SCTV parody, Jerry Lewis Live on the Champs Elysees. True to SCTV form, it’s a comic fever dream blurring Jerry’s French fans, the annual terrors of the Lewis telethon and Scorsese’s King of Comedy. It’ll make you feel good, a lot.