5012topDoll

Beyond the Valley of the Dolls


DVD SAVANT

This is my film review and it FREAKS ME OUT!  Girlie-art legend Russ Meyer and then- tyro critic Roger Ebert fashion the most garish, vulgar and absurd satire of wild Hollywood that they can think of, a camp vision of joy straight from the dizzy imagination of a breast-obsessed glamour photographer. All your favorites are here — Erica Gavin, Dolly Read, Marcia McBroom, Cynthia Meyers, Edy Williams.


Beyond the Valley of the Dolls
+ The Seven Minutes
Region B Blu-ray + PAL DVD
Arrow Video (UK)
1970 / Color / 1:85 widescreen / 109 min. / Street Date January 18, 2016 / Available from Amazon UK £17.99
Starring Dolly Read, Cynthia Meyers, Marcia McBroom, Erica Gavin, John LaZar, Michael Blodgett, David Gurian, Edy Williams, Phyllis Davis, Harrison Page, Duncan McLeod, Charles Napier, Haji, Pam Grier, Coleman Francis, The Strawberry Alarm Clock.
Cinematography Fred J. Koenecamp
Editors Dann Cahn, Dick Wormell
Original Music Stu Phillips
Written by Roger Ebert, Russ Meyer
Produced and Directed by Russ Meyer

Reviewed by Glenn Erickson

Young reviewer Roger Ebert had a strong background in film. He was capable of dishing the cinema-speak on European and Japanese classics and had a good handle on pop culture movies as well. Even as he complained that little children were being shown the gruesome Night of the Living Dead, he wrote that he thought it was a great horror film for adults. Ebert’s special yen for straight-out exploitation caused him to happily follow the exploits of the independent filmmaker Russ Meyer. The ex-girlie photographer invented the ‘nudie-cutie’ peep show attraction and from there moved on to various adults-only comedies that exploited bodacious female nudity. When Ebert championed Meyer in the legit press, and Meyer befriended him. When Hollywood imploded with the success of Easy Rider, panicked executives at Fox got the crazy idea of hiring Meyer to make a sequel to Jacqueline Susann’s trashy show-biz exposé The Valley of the Dolls. Realizing that no studio scribe could adapt to his weird style, Meyer hired Roger Ebert to write it for him.

The two outsiders ran amuck in the dream factory. Because Meyer was always under budget the studio gave him the freedom to ‘play with the toy trains’ just as Orson Welles had thirty years before. Meyer’s prior micro-budgeted epics had been campy comedy-dramas packed with absurd drama and overheated characters from trashy potboilers. And with copious, gratuitous, unashamed and unabashed female nudity. The sequel Beyond the Valley of the Dolls is not a sequel, but an eccentric, cartoonish satire of Hollywood decadence. Meyer’s ‘vision’ has nothing to do with reality, and everything to do with the public perception of a town of glamorous hedonists and wild orgies, ruled by greed, lust and rock ‘n’ roll. And topless women.

The story launches from Valley’s basic setup of three newcomers to Tinsel Town. They’re an all-female rock group, something fairly unheard-of in 1970: Kelly, Casey and Petronella (Dolly Read, Cynthia Myers & Marcia McBroom). Accompanied by their young manager Harris Allsworth (David Gurian), the three women have no sooner arrived than Kelly’s aunt Susan Lake (Phyllis Davis) invites them to a wild party given by the hip & happening rock promoter Ronnie Barzell, aka “Z-Man” (John LaZar). The band gets a new name, “The Carrie Nations,” and the girls find new romantic partners. Everybody hits on everybody but Petronella meets medical student/waiter Emerson Thorne (Harrison Page), Casey is eventually wooed by lesbian fashion maven Roxanne (Erica Gavin) and Kelly is given an amorous full court press by Z-Man himself. Abandoned, Harris is picked up by the nymphomaniac porn star Ashley St. Ives (Edy Williams). Also figuring in the tangled web of flaky relationships is the pretty boy/gigolo Lance Rocke (Michael Blodgett), Susan’s repressed and impotent business manager Porter Hall (Duncan McLeod) and pro boxer Randy Black (jim Iglehart), who forcibly takes Petronella away from the sweet-hearted Emerson. Susan is shocked when her former love Baxter Wolfe (Charles Napier) re-enters the scene. Petty jealousies and drug-induced madness finally come to a head when Z-Man, spurned by the forceful Kelly, goes murderously nuts, with both a sword and a .45 automatic, igniting a bloodbath worthy of Helter Skelter.

1970 was a year of studio auctions, sales of back lots and surely the retirement of a ton of studio executives that couldn’t handle the ‘new Hollywood.’ 20th-Fox was putting out X- and R-rated pictures left and right, as if convinced that America wanted its movies as trashy as possible. Michael Sarne’s Myra Breckenridge was probably the worst offender, being both ridiculously vulgar and witless to boot. It employed the film critic Rex Reed as an actor, pretty much putting an end to his credibility in any capacity. Beyond the Valley of the Dolls has an edge because Ebert’s script is a self-conscious study of trash filmmaking. Yes, the movie subscribes wholly to Meyer’s patented ‘Breasts ‘R Us’ philosophy. In this cartoonish catalog of Tinsel Town excess most everybody is grossly oversexed. The sweet Petronella, the ambitious Kelly and the depressive Casey find themselves up to their necks in weirdos. Cross dressers and crazy old people provide variety in the party crowds that dance mindlessly at Z-Man’s parties; Ashley St. Ives gyrates and seduces as if her live were un unending orgasm. Wandering through the crowded dance floor is Meyer favorite model Haji, nude and painted solid black. She’s in about eight shots, each of which seems less than two seconds long. Or is that only because we want them to last longer?

The paper-thin characters are plastic ‘beautiful people’ taken not from reality but from the cheap images in magazines and TV commercials. Everything is purposely stylized like a Bad Movie. All the dialogue is arch; people speak in declaratory sound bites that instantly diagnose their problem or accuse those that offend them. When Baxter sees Susan he recaps their past relationship in two sentences, announcing his intention to break off his engagement and marry her. People shout wonderfully inane/overstated thoughts, the best being Z-Man’s inspired exclamation, “This is my happening and it FREAKS ME OUT!”

Other lines hit new highs of grotesquery — both Ashley and a painted old crone try out the come-on, “I’d like to strap you on sometime!” In this universe, aberrant sex = sick violence. When Z-Man flips out he purrs, You will drink the black sperm of my vengeance.” Another throwaway line makes a cheap joke about Nazis and ovens. Today Beyond seems benign — but in 1970 its content was R-rated culture porn, begging to be labeled execrable trash. In other words, good old Roger was having the time of his life.

Although everybody we see makes a claim on being “in” with the latest trends, nothing in sight resembles real youth culture. The women are as artificial as the characters in the animated Josie and the Pussycats come to life, many wearing impractical party outfits. If all of Los Angeles were costumed and art-directed as in Beyond the Valley of the Dolls, we’d all spend our days throwing up.

Meyer and Ebert know that that their crazy send-up of Hollywood is a ridiculous exaggeration. Remember that Russ Meyer is an outsider whose former audience was lonely guys and servicemen that fantasized over his photos of pliable-looking women with Amazon-grade breasts. Only recently had it become it hip for college students to glom movies like Mudhoney and Vixen: the lines formed for Meyer on one side of the street, and Jean-Luc Godard on the other.

The Carrie Nations perform in montages that represent their concerts and rise to commercial success. They come off as freeze-dried fakes, andeven Dolly Read’s good singing is dubbed, by Lynn Carey. Also at the parties is The Strawberry Alarm Clock a real Top-40 band riding the fading psychedelic trend. Richard Rush’s perfectly phony Haight-Ashbury epic Psych-Out had exploited The Alarm Clock’s pop hit Incense and Peppermints, burying any hope of authenticity. Being a trendy imitation of something real in youth culture that commercialism had already stamped out, the band is a perfect fit for Beyond.

Meyer’s editorial style is distinctive. As if afraid to let things get boring, he keeps the screen alive by constantly cutting, often arbitrarily. The makes cross cutting makes some sense in the party scenes, but most every scene becomes a party scene or a music montage. I noticed a long time ago in The Super Vixens that he’s really tight with the nudes — the stunning silhouettes of his stacked actresses always cut long before we’ve absorbed them. On one level this is a tease, like a kid in school flashing a picture from a dirty book and then running away. The principle might be, ‘Always keep ’em begging for more.’ Or maybe Meyer is trying to keep his audience in a state of sustained arousal.

Most of Meyer’s cast had never been in a film before, but most were also experienced professionals — girlie models and Playboy centerfolds that took the business seriously. For them Beyond was a big-time job for a pro director who would make them look good and treat them fairly. Erica Gavin and a couple of the other women had starred for Meyer earlier, as had Charles Napier. With John LaZar Meyer made a perfect bit of casting — the man’s face carries a permanent look of wanton perversion. Dolly Read is forever being described as the ‘girl next door’ type. Her smile does project enough personality to break through the plastic sex-dream image of rosy-fleshed Playboy pictorials.

Meyer’s big studio picture is a comedy original that teases viewers with their own absurd fantasies of the imagined wild life of luxury and sex behind the tabloid TV headline stories. Either that, or it’s for Meyer’s audience of middle-aged squares that read Playboy in search of thrills, with the vision of a topless woman being the culture’s highest ambition. It’s an original freak show straight from Russ Meyer’s personal dream life, and as such is the work of an artist. If Robert Crumb had been bitten by the filmmaking bug and put his personal sex fantasies onto film, imagine the kind of movies he might have made.


Arrow’s Region B Blu-ray of Beyond the Valley of the Dolls is accompanied by the companion feature produced on Russ Meyer’s Fox contract, the atypical drama The Seven Minutes. An attempt at a fairly straight story, it’s an odd misfire that helps us better understand where Meyer was coming from. The Irving Wallace book source is sort of an “Inherit the Wind” that substitutes pornography for Darwinism. The script is a talky screed showing a common book clerk caught in a manufactured scandal driven by a politician up for re-election, aided by some society bluenoses and a Catholic Church representative who might as well be a 1971 Witchfinder General.

Russ Meyer’s cutting style is even more exaggerated, with a cut coming every three seconds or so, no matter what is happening on screen. Meyer confects to have plenty of parallel actions to cut between, but the preponderance of close-ups and lack of variable pacing turn the movie into a big headache. He seems most interested in the sex scenes, which arrange to ‘almost’ show nipples, etc., so as to skirt the ratings. The show’s tease factor isn’t as high, because even Edy Williams’ role is a straight one, and there are none of Meyer’s cartoonish, in-your-face displays of nudity, his ‘special visual effects.’ As the characters do little more than rattle off their dialogue in as efficient a manner as possible, our involvement is kept to a minimum. We’re told that after his two Fox films Russ Meyer retreated to independent filmmaking, but I doubt the reason was any artistic difficulty. He probably came to that decision the first time the Fox accountants reported that he had earned no profits, even after Variety reported Beyond taking in millions.

Helpful corrections from Shaun K. Chang.


Arrow Video’s Region B Blu-ray + PAL DVD of Beyond the Valley of the Dolls is a fine-quality encoding of these very unique big-studio releases. For many years Fox behaved as if BTVOTD was a dirty family secret, to be kept in the closet; I remember a laserdisc being delayed and then becoming difficult to find. The transfer is very good, as sharp and colorful as any Meyer Hound would want. All those perfect-complexioned people, with all that visible skin, suggest that body makeup and the corps of experts to apply it was a major item in the budget.

On the Region B Blu-ray disc with Beyond is a tall stack of extras repurposed from a previous Fox special edition (2007? 2008?). I’ve reprinted Arrow’s description below. Meyer fans will love every bit of the jokey interviews with cast members, all of whom look back fondly on their crazy-wild days in the Meyer movie machine. John LaZar, still looking like an agent of Beezelbub, does the main introduction. His face already distorted by his malady, Roger Ebert helps position the Meyer films in an understandable context. Younger viewers will learn about the couple of years when Hollywood went sex & drugs- crazy, while those of us who lived through the period will be pleased to see how the actors have aged. Of the cast of discoveries and exploitation names, only Charles Napier and Michael Blodgett continued to be all that visible. One featurette puts Cynthia Myers and Erica Gavin together to discuss their big sex scene. They come across as fun actresses, not sex maniacs.

The Seven Minutes is on the PAL disc, in a clean transfer with excellent sound. It’s funny to hear Fox library music cues like Street Scene and Love is a Many-Splendored Thing incorporated into Stu Phillips’ music score. The main extra here is a vintage David Del Valle public access TV show from 1987, an interview with Russ Meyer and Yvette Vickers. Meyer is cooperative and we see clips from several of his pictures. Del Valle tells us that BTVOTD will be the subject of their second show, but apparently that didn’t happen.

I have two personal Meyer-land encounters to relate. Around 1986 I was at a post house on Sunset doing a TV commercial when I heard that Russ Meyer was in the building. I snooped a peek into his film transfer session just to see if he was surrounded by naked women. No, he was timing a transfer of The Seven Minutes alone, dressed suitable for a day of golf. But he called me in!   Only a couple of minutes later did it become apparent that he had mistaken me for the sales rep for the post facility, and I excused myself. All I remember was his noticing a little gold Cub Scout medallion I wore on my editorial work jacket. Whenever someone asked about it, I quoted the Boy Scout Oath, the trustworthy-loyal-faithful pledge. Meyer thought that was amusing. I did not receive an invitation to star in his next picture.

Edy Williams was just as businesslike, but more like a piranha fish. James Ursini had talked me into attending a 1992 film fan convention, and I went along because I wanted to see what Barbara Steele looked like in person. In the parking lot we were practically kidnapped by Ms. Williams, who needed someone to carry in a couple of heavy boxes of photos she was going to sign, and a standee. Looking up her age, I see that she is only eleven years older than I am. But at age 51 wearing a glitzy leotard in the morning light she looked very hard and wiry. We carried her boxes. She somehow walked faster than we could, despite wearing high heels that made her half a foot taller than me (the big hair helped) even though the stats say that she’s actually two inches shorter. In payment for our services she harassed the convention officials until we were let in for free, an interesting touch — I got the idea that she didn’t want to owe us anything, even for such a small favor. After we got to her table her attitude was Beware The Dogs. Experienced showgirls develop practical, necessary social skills for the curt brush-off, and hers was a veritable atomic force field. I’m sure that in a different circumstance she’d be as easy to talk to as my sister-in-law.


On a scale of Excellent, Good, Fair, and Poor,
Beyond the Valley of the Dolls Region B Blu-ray + PAL DVD rates:
Movie: Unique
Video: Excellent
Sound: Excellent
Supplements: Two commentaries on Beyond the Valley of the Dolls by co-screenwriter Roger Ebert and various actors. Introduction by John LaZar. Featurettes: Above, Beneath and Beyond the Valley: The Making of a Musical-Horror-Sex-Comedy; Look On Up at the Bottom with composer Stu Phillips and three members of the Carrie Nations discussing the film’s music; The Best of Beyond, favourite moments selected by cast and crew members; Sex, Drugs, Music & Murder: Signs of the Time, Baby!, a look at the late 1960s culture that spawned Beyond the Valley of the Dolls; Casey & Roxanne: The Love Scene discussed by participants Erica Gavin and Cynthia Myers. Screen tests for Michael Blodgett, Cynthia Myers, Harrison Page, Marcia McBroom; Photo galleries, multiple trailers, Booklet featuring new writing on the film by critic Kat Ellinger.
Pal DVD disc with Meyer’s The Seven Minutes a 20th Fox release from 1971. David De Valle’s 1987 interview with director Meyer and his former model Yvette Vickers; Trailer.

Deaf and Hearing-impaired Friendly? YES; Subtitles: English (both features)
Packaging: One Blu-ray and one DVD disc in Keep case
Reviewed: January 25, 2016

Visit DVD Savant’s Main Column Page
Glenn Erickson answers most reader mail:
dvdsavant@mindspring.com

Text © Copyright 2016 Glenn Erickson